|

All That Wheezes Is Not Asthma: Diagnosing the
Mimics
Especially when the standard therapy for asthma
has failed to produce improvement, the clinician should be alert
to signs of other conditions that can closely resemble asthma, ranging
from congestive heart failure to vocal cord dysfunction.
By Francisco J. Soto, MD, and Kalpalatha K.
Guntupalli, MD
| Dr. Soto is clinical instructor and Dr.
Guntupalli is professor of medicine in the Pulmonary/Critical
Care Division at Baylor College of Medicine in Houston. Dr.
Guntupalli is also associate chief of medicine, chief of the
pulmonary/critical care unit, and director of the medical intensive
care unit at Ben Taub General Hospital in Houston. |
Wheezing, or high-pitched adventitious sounds superimposed on the
normal sounds of breathing, occurs when air flows rapidly through
narrowed bronchi. Clinically, it should be viewed as a nonspecific
manifestation of airway obstruction. Asthma is its most common cause,
especially when the wheezing is episodic and the patient is young,
but other medical conditions that can be mistaken for asthma should
be considered. In particular, when the standard therapy for asthma
has failed to produce improvement, a differential diagnosis needs
to be undertaken or revisited.
In this article, we will discuss a variety of conditions that can
be labeled as asthma, leading not only to delayed diagnosis but
also to inappropriate treatment. The differential diagnosis of a
patient with wheezing should also include diseases that affect the
upper airways. The list of conditions is long, and we will focus
only on the more common conditions that the clinician is likely
to encounter.
back to top
Preliminary Indications in the History and
Physical Examination
A number of features in the history are helpful in establishing
the etiology of wheezing (see table below). In children, the clinician
should suspect foreign body aspiration, especially if the symptoms
started rather suddenly; congenital heart disease; and cystic fibrosis,
if a patient has a history of gastrointestinal or upper airway symptoms.
Adults may also present with wheezing due to foreign body aspiration.
Up to a third of adult patients with foreign body aspiration do
not recall choking episodes. First-time wheezing in an older adult,
especially a smoker, should alert the physician to the possibility
of lung cancer. Both malignant lesions and benign tumors such as
squamous papilloma, leiomyoma, bronchial cyst adenoma, or carcinoid
tumor can present with hoarseness, hemoptysis, inspiratory stridor
or wheezing, but the benign airway tumors are rare. Sudden onset
of wheezing in adults might be due to left ventricular failure ("cardiac
asthma"), pulmonary embolism, aspiration pneumonitis, or a foreign
body. Other clues such as the timing of symptoms (wheezing late
at night, for example) and the presence of orthopnea, dyspnea on
exertion, peripheral edema, or paroxysmal nocturnal dyspnea are
also helpful.
Disorders Associated with Wheezing
According to Age, Onset, and Course
| Age |
Infants and children
|
- Congenital anomalies
- Bronchopulmonary dysplasia
- Bronchomalacia
- Vascular rings
- Cystic fibrosis
- Foreign body aspiration
|
Adults
|
- Asthma
- Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
(COPD)
- Congestive heart failure (CHF)
- Primary endobronchial tumors
- Endobronchial metastasis (from colon,
breast, melanoma, kidney, pancreas)
|
|
|
| Onset |
Acute
|
- Asthma
- CHF
- Pneumonia
- Pulmonary embolism
- Anaphylaxis
- Aspiration syndromes
- Foreign body aspiration
|
Insidious
|
- Bronchogenic carcinoma
- Tracheal tumor
- Endobronchial metastasis
- CHF
|
|
|
| Course |
Intermittent
|
- Aspiration syndromes
- COPD
- Asthma
- CHF
- Carcinoid syndrome
- Vocal cord dysfunction
|
Persistent
|
- Endobronchial tumor
- Tracheal stenosis
- Bilateral vocal cord paralysis
- Asthma
- Churg-Strauss syndrome
|
Progressive
|
- COPD
- Tumors
- Pulmonary infiltrates/eosinophilia syndromes
|
|
|
|
A knowledge of the anatomy of the upper airway‹the air-conducting
passages from the nose or mouth to the main carina‹is helpful in
understanding the pathophysiology of some of the asthma mimics.
The upper airway comprises three sectors: the anatomic spaces around
the mouth and nose that can be potentially occupied (as in Ludwig's
angina), the larynx, and the trachea. The larynx, which extends
from the root of the tongue to the trachea, consists of the supraglottic
larynx (epiglottis, aryepiglottic folds, and false vocal cords),
the glottis (structures at the level of the vocal cords, including
arytenoid cartilages), and the subglottis (the 1.5- to 2-cm segment
of the airway surrounded by the cricoid cartilage). The trachea
(10 to 13 cm long and 13 to 25 mm in coronal diameter in men, 10
to 21 mm in women) is conceptually divided in two by the thoracic
inlet. The extrathoracic trachea is 2 to 4 cm long, extending from
the lower edge of the cricoid cartilage to the thoracic inlet, and
is located 1 to 3 cm above the suprasternal notch. The intrathoracic
trachea extends 6 to 9 cm from the thoracic inlet to the main carina.
In the wheezing patient, characteristics of the voice may be helpful
in pointing to a diagnosis. Changes in the voice, such as the so-called
hot potato voice (the patient talks as if he had a hot potato in
his mouth) associated with oral abscess and Ludwig's angina, are
helpful when trying to determine the etiology or location of the
obstruction (see table below).
|
Vocal Attributes
and Associated Airway Problems
|
| Symptom |
Disorder
|
| Hoarseness |
Unilateral vocal cord paralysis
Croup
|
| Muffled voice |
Supraglottic process |
| "Hot
potato" voice |
Oral abcess
Ludwig's angina
|
| "Barking" cough |
Laryngotracheobronchitis |
| No
hoarseness |
Epiglottitis |
| Drooling, dysphagia |
Epiglottitis |
| Fever without cough |
Epiglottitis |
| Monotone, hurried sentences,
inspiratory pause |
Bilateral vocal cord paralysis |
| Suppressed laughter or
cough |
Bilateral vocal cord paralysis |
|
On inspection, thyroidectomy or tracheostomy scars should alert
the examiner to consider vocal cord damage or tracheal/laryngeal
stenosis. Jugular venous distention might be associated with congestive
heart failure and cardiac asthma. In a patient who looks septic,
neck swelling should alert the clinician to a possible deep space
infection, such as Ludwig's angina. The presence of facial flushing
(carcinoid tumor), vasculitic skin lesions (Churg-Strauss), or venous
congestion (venous thrombosis) in the physical exam also contributes
to the assessment of wheezing. The presence of clubbing in a young
patient with wheezing raises the possibility of underlying congenital
heart disease or bronchiectasis secondary to cystic fibrosis. In
an older patient, clubbing may be associated with bronchogenic carcinoma.
Any evidence of residual neurologic deficit in a patient whose gag
reflex is absent due to previous strokes indicates increased risk
for recurrent aspiration.
On palpation, cervical or axillary lymphadenopathy may be related
to an intrathoracic process, such as bronchogenic carcinoma or lymphoma.
Thyromegaly or a neck mass may be responsible for the compression
of the upper airway.
back to top
Interpreting Chest Sounds
On auscultation, the clinician should listen for signs of cardiac
disease, including the presence of a loud second heart sound, a
third heart sound, or a murmur, which may suggest pulmonary hypertension
with venous thromboembolic disease, congestive heart failure, or
valvular heart disease. The tone, timing, and location of the wheezing
provide additional clues (see table below).

Any monotonal wheezing, whether inspiratory, expiratory, or both,
may be indicative of structural or functional upper airway disease.
Auscultation during a wheezing episode can be very helpful in further
characterizing the patient's breathing problem. However, the findings
may vary from episode to episode. Also, while the timing and apparent
location of wheezing may be significant, even the most localized
obstruction can produce diffuse bilateral sounds. (See table below,
for possible causes of unilateral wheezing.) The typical wheezing
during expiration implies bronchiolar disease, either primary (due
to structural change) or secondary (as in air trapping), both of
which can be seen in asthma. The patient with asthma may wheeze
during inspiration as well.
|
Causes
of Unilateral Wheezing
- Foreign body
- Airway stenosis
- Bronchomalacia
- Airway compression
- Vascular enlargement
- Lymphadenopathy
- Cyst
- Neoplasm (external compression)
- Endobronchial tumors
- Primary malignancy (bronchogenic carcinoma)
- Benign tumors
- Bronchial cyst adnenoma
- Squamous papilloma
- Leiomyoma
- Carcinoid (might behave aggressively)
- Malignant metastasis from breast, colon, rectum, pancreas,
kidney, thyroid, or skin
|
Certain auscultatory features help to differentiate wheezing from
stridor. "Stridor" is a Latin word meaning a hiss, grating, creaking,
whistle, or shriek. In asthma, wheezing is usually diffuse and polyphonic,
occurring prominently during expiration. Monotonic wheezing heard
louder at the level of the larynx indicates an upper airway obstruction,
regardless of the etiology. Stridor is heard prominently when the
airflow is maximal or the airway lumen decreases. Inspiratory stridor
strongly suggests palatal, tracheal, laryngeal, or epiglottic obstruction,
and may indicate a medical emergency. Expiratory stridor suggests
an obstruction in the lower airways or in a bronchus, as caused
by a foreign body.
back to top
Turning to Spirometry for Clarification
Spirometry can be helpful in further delineating the site and cause
of wheezing. A low forced expiratory volume in one second (FEV1),
with significant reversibility after administration of a bronchodilator,
indicates asthma. In patients with normal spirometry findings, asthma
can be diagnosed by bronchoprovocation with methacholine or histamine.
The configuration and changes of the spirometric flow-volume loop
(see examples below) help in diagnosing other conditions such as
upper airway obstruction.
A flow-volume loop can also help to differentiate between variable
intrathoracic and extrathoracic obstruction. However, it is important
to remember that spirometric abnormalities are not seen until obstruction
is advanced (see table below).
|
Spirometric
Diagnosis of Obstruction: Hints and Caveats
- FEV1 is a poor indicator of large airway obstruction
- In general, the airway abnormality has to decrease the
tracheal lumen to less than 8mm before the flow-volume loop
(FVL) is abnormal.
- In patients with severe COPD, even a significant tracheal
stenosis may not be apparent on FVL.
- FVL abnormality indicates the functional rather than the
anatomic severity of the obstruction
- Baseline resting stridor usually indicates that the airway
lumen is less than 5mm.
|
There are three main patterns of obstruction identified by the
flow-volume loop: variable intrathoracic, variable extrathoracic,
and fixed (see table below). A variable lesion is one subject to
changes in airway pressures, which differ by location. Airway diameter
and flows are influenced by surrounding atmospheric pressures in
the extrathoracic airway and by pleural pressures in the intrathoracic
airway.
|
Causes of Variable and Fixed Upper Airway
Obstruction
|
|
Variable Extrathoracic
- Tracheomalacia
- Vocal cord paralysis
- Vocal cord dysfunction
- Vocal cord polyps
|
Variable Intrathoracic
- Tracheomalacia of intrathoracic airway
- Tumors
- Mediastinal adenopathy
|
Fixed
- Tracheal stenosis
- Subglottic (as caused by intubation, Wegener's granulomatosis)
- Tracheal (as caused by intubation)
- Tracheal tumors
- Foreign body
|
Variable extrathoracic obstruction. During inspiration,
the pressure around the extrathoracic airway is atmospheric, and
the transmural pressure favors narrowing. This is not clinically
important in normal individuals. However, in the presence of a nonrigid
extrathoracic obstruction, such as bilateral vocal cord paralysis,
there is a decrease in airway pressure distal to the obstruction,
which causes further narrowing and obstruction of the airway (see
illustration below). The flow-volume loop will show a flattening
of the inspiratory component. Other examples of variable extrathoracic
obstruction are tracheomalacia of the extrathoracic trachea and
vocal cord dysfunction.

|
Variable extrathoracic
obstruction. During forced
expiration, intratracheal pressure (Ptr) becomes greater than
atmospheric pressure (Patm), and airway size remains near
normal (left). During inspiration, Patm is higher than Ptr,
worsening the obstruction and decreasing inspiratory airflow
(center). The flow-volume loop shows flattening of the inspiratory
limb.
|
Variable intrathoracic obstruction. During forced expiration,
the pleural pressure becomes positive relative to the airway pressure,
which favors narrowing of the intrathoracic airway. In a normal
person this effect does not have clinical significance, but in the
presence of an intrathoracic disorder (such as intrathoracic tracheomalacia)
it may worsen the obstruction (see illustration below). In the flow-volume
loop it is seen as a flattening of the expiratory component.
|
Variable intrathoracic
obstruction. During forced
expiration, the intrapleural pressure (Ppl) becomes greater
than the intratracheal pressure (Ptr), worsening the obstruction
and decreasing expiratory flow (left). During inspiration,
Ptr is greater than Ppl, improving the airway diameter (center).
The flow-volume loop shows flattening of the expiratory limb.
|
Fixed upper airway obstruction. When the airway obstruction
is rigid, as in tracheal stenosis or intraluminal tumors (benign
or malignant), the flow will be limited during both inspiration
and expiration, flattening both components of the flow-volume loop
(see example below).
|
Flow-volume loop
of a fixed airway obstruction.
Inspiratory and expiratory flow rates are decreased, leading
to flattening of both limbs.
|
back to top
Roles of Diagnostic Imaging and Endoscopy
Plain chest radiographs are helpful in the workup of a patient
with wheezing. Consolidation in a patient with eosinophilia suggests
one of the eosinophilic syndromes. Infiltrates in the superior segment
of the lower lobes or posterior segment of the upper lobes indicate
aspiration pneumonitis. The combination of an enlarged cardiac silhouette,
cephalization of blood flow, and pleural effusions points to congestive
heart failure as the cause of wheezing.
Atelectasis of a segment of one or more lobes suggests volume loss
due to the presence of an endobronchial tumor or a foreign body.
Plain x-ray films may show hilar or mediastinal lymphadenopathy,
contributing to airway compression and volume loss.
Plain neck films may show narrowing of the subglottic space on
posteroanterior views, known as the steeple sign, which is the classic
sign for croup. The lateral neck film is more helpful for diagnosing
epiglottitis, showing a swollen epiglottis, hypopharyngeal dilatation,
or both. However, the overall sensitivity of neck films for diagnosis
of either croup or epiglottitis is only 38% to 54%.
Computed tomography (CT) scanning of the chest and neck is helpful
when evaluating airway compression due to lymph nodes, tumors, and
other lesions. The disadvantage of conventional CT, however, is
the inability to image the trachea along its long axis. Spiral CT
with multiplanar and three-dimensional reconstructions allows better
assessment of the extent of disease. Some studies have shown similar
sensitivity and specificity when spiral CT was compared with bronchoscopy
in the evaluation of upper airway structural abnormalities, such
as intraluminal tumors (benign and malignant) or tracheal stenosis.
Magnetic resonance imaging can also be used and offers several
advantages, including resolution without contrast injection, good
mediastinal evaluation, and estimation of the length and degree
of tracheal obstruction.
In recent years, rhinolaryngoscopy and flexible fiberoptic bronchoscopy
performed under local anesthesia have dramatically improved diagnostic
accuracy for a large number of conditions that can present as "wheezing"
accompanied by other respiratory symptoms. The inspection of the
upper and lower airways might be the final test to confirm diagnoses
such as vocal cord paralysis, vocal cord dysfunction, laryngeal
polyps and granulomas, tracheal stenosis, and endotracheal or endobronchial
lesions.
Following are two case examples that will illustrate the diagnosis
and treatment of asthma mimics.
back to top
Case Example: Vocal Cord Dysfunction
A 32-year-old obese woman has been receiving treatment for asthma
in a clinic for five years. Her asthma has been difficult to control,
with recurrent episodes of exacerbation in spite of appropriate
therapy. During the previous year she had made 10 visits to the
emergency room, and she is currently taking maximum doses of inhaled
steroids, long-acting beta-agonists, oral prednisone 20 mg/day,
leukotriene inhibitors, and inhaled albuterol as needed. Her spirometry
results in the clinic were normal, but a methacholine challenge
test was positive for reactive airway disease. During the last emergency
room visit, the physician found the patient in moderate to severe
respiratory distress, anxious, and with bilateral diffuse wheezing,
which was prominent over the neck. The patient was hypoxemic, but
there was no increased P(A-a)O2 gradient. Very astutely, the physician
provided care for the "asthma attack" but at the same time requested
a laryngoscopic evaluation, which confirmed the diagnosis of vocal
cord dysfunction (VCD) (see endoscopic image below).
|
Vocal cord dysfunction.
Direct laryngoscopy shows the anterior two thirds of the vocal
cords approximating during inspiration (left arrow), leaving
a small diamond-shaped "chink" opening posteriorly (right
arrow). This finding confirms the diagnosis of VCD.
|
General features. In VCD, the anterior two-thirds
of the vocal cord close, leaving only a 4- to 5-mm diamond-shaped
posterior "chink" for airflow. The airway closure usually occurs
during inspiration but can be seen during expiration as well. In
the past, this disorder has been called factitious asthma, hysterical
stridor, Munchausen's stridor, psychogenic upper airway obstruction,
and fake asthma. Patients may present with wheezing, stridor, or
both. Vocal cord dysfunction has been described in patients as young
as 3 and as old as 82 years old, but most commonly it is seen in
the second to fourth decade, in overweight patients, and among health
professionals (around 25% of cases). A number of these patients
have a prior diagnosis of asthma, generally considered refractory
to standard therapy. (It is important to remember that VCD and asthma
are not mutually exclusive.) About half take oral steroids.
A study from the National Jewish Center in Denver identified 95
patients diagnosed with VCD by laryngoscopic evaluation. Of these,
53 had concomitant asthma. The patients in the group without asthma
were receiving daily prednisone at an average daily dose of 29 mg
and had made 9.7 emergency room visits and were admitted to the
hospital 5.9 times in the year prior to presentation. About a third
of these patients had been intubated.
Acute attacks can be accompanied by hoarseness and dysphonia. The
patient may point to the throat as the cause of respiratory distress.
Attacks can be precipitated by upper respiratory infections and
irritants such as dust and smoke. When the problem is purely VCD,
the patient rarely is awakened by it at night. The physical exam
may be helpful but is unreliable in differentiating VCD from asthma.
Diagnostic keys. A high index of suspicion in a
patient refractory to asthma treatment or presenting with upper
airway obstruction is crucial to making the diagnosis of VCD. Stressful
situations may increase the degree of paradoxical vocal cord motion.
Between episodes, spirometry results and flow volume loop curves
are normal. During the acute attack, hypoxemia may be present, but
usually without an increased P(A-a)O2 (alveolar-arterial oxygen
tension) gradient. The spirometry readings might show a flattening
of the inspiratory limb of the flow-volume loop. Laryngoscopy during
the acute attack is the gold standard for establishing the diagnosis.
Adduction of the anterior two thirds of the cords, causing a posterior
diamond-shaped opening to appear, is usually seen during inspiration
but may occur during expiration or both.
Therapy. In VCD, it is essential to withdraw unnecessary
treatment, such as steroids. Speech therapy and psychotherapy have
been used with some success. During the acute attack, offering reassurance
to the patient is important. Heliox (80:20 helium-oxygen mixture,
a low-density gas) increases airflow across the narrowed airway
and may avert the need for invasive treatment. Overall, the results
of the long-term therapies seem to be disappointing.
back to top
Case Example: Airway Obstruction
A 33-year-old nonsmoking man presented to the emergency department
with shortness of breath, cough, and wheezing of 10 days' duration.
One year before this visit, the patient had a lengthy hospitalization
after a motor vehicle accident and required intubation and prolonged
mechanical ventilation. He also had a history of asthma during childhood.
Because of his symptoms and the history of asthma, he was given
several bronchodilator treatments, but his response was minimal.
The patient was admitted to the intensive care unit, where he was
found to be tachycardic and in moderate respiratory distress. The
clinician noted that his wheezing was more intense on auscultation
of the neck. A tracheostomy scar was found. Based on the finding
of clear lungs with stridor, portable spirometry was performed (see
figure below)
.

|
Fixed airway obstruction.
This flow-volume loop shows flattening of both inspiratory
and expiratory limbs, consistent with the diagnosis of tracheal
stenosis.
|
A laryngoscopy showed subglottic tracheal stenosis at the site
of previous tracheostomy, which confirmed the diagnosis of upper
airway obstruction secondary to tracheal stenosis.
General features. Upper airway obstruction can
be divided into structural and functional obstruction (see table
below). Anatomic obstructions are caused by lesions or diseases
that narrow the airway lumen, such as tracheal stenosis. Functional
obstructions, on the other hand, might not have an obvious, visible
lesion but can cause dynamic collapse of the airway during the respiratory
cycle (as in obstructive sleep apnea).
|
Causes of
Upper Airway Obstruction
|
|
Anatomic
Soft tissue infection
- Ludwig's angina
- Retropharyngeal abcess
Laryngeal or tracheal tumors
Intraluminal obstruction
- Laryngeal stenosis (as occurs with intubation)
- Tracheal stenosis (as occurs after tracheostomy)
Foreign body (especially in children)
Infiltrating diseases
- Sarcoidosis
- Amyloidosis
- Wegener's granulomatosis
Web, stricture, or ring (especially in children)
Mucosal edema associated with burns or reflux
Laryngotracheobronchitis or epiglottitis
Extrinsic compression
- Goiter
- Innominate artery aneurysm
- Mediastinal masses
- Esophageal foreign body
- Esophageal achalasia
Mucous ball from transtracheal catheters
|
|
Functional
Vocal cord paralysis
- Unilateral (as in laryngeal nerve damage)
- Bilateral (as in post thyroidectomy)
Vocal cord dysfunction
Laryngospasm
Obstructive sleep apnea
Tracheo- and bronchomalacia
Upper airway laxity (as in sleep apnea)
|
|
Worsening symptoms occur when demand for minute ventilation increases
through a narrow opening, as during exercise, or when the narrowed
lumen is further compromised due to an upper respiratory infection.
In the case described above, the previous intubation, tracheostomy,
or both probably caused the tracheal stenosis, since endotracheal
intubation can lead to damage of the glottis with such consequences
as vocal cord paralysis. Factors that have been found to increase
the risk of laryngeal injury include tracheostomy, severe laryngeal
trauma during extubation, large endotracheal tube caliber, oral
intubation, severe respiratory failure, diabetes, and female gender.
The incidence of all types of injury to the larynx after intubation
ranges from 63% to 94%. Significant airway stenosis occurs in 6%
to 12% of cases. Because of the risk of intubation-associated airway
injury, tracheostomy is generally recommended after two weeks of
endotracheal intubation. The incidence of tracheal stenosis secondary
to intubation was as high as 20% in the past but has waned since
the introduction of low-pressure, high-volume cuffs. The incidence
of tracheal stenosis following tracheotomy varies, and it can occur
at the site of the stoma, cuff, or tip. Severe stenosis requiring
surgical intervention occurs in less than 8% of patients.
Diagnostic keys. A history of intubation with or
without tracheostomy, progressive shortness of breath, stridor,
and a normal lung exam should prompt the physician to evaluate for
the presence of tracheal stenosis.
Treatment. Emergency treatment of upper airway
obstruction depends on the etiology of the obstruction. Racemic
epinephrine can be used to treat croup and may also be used empirically
in the treatment of laryngeal edema. Heliox has been shown to decrease
the turbulent airflow generated at the area of obstruction and the
flow-resistive work. Heliox has been used for postextubation stridor,
tracheal stenosis, intrinsic compression, VCD, status asthmaticus,
and angioedema. It is only a temporizing solution until the primary
event is resolved or more definitive therapy is instituted.
For soft tissue infection such as Ludwig's angina or retropharyngeal
abscess, surgical drainage and intravenous antibiotics are indicated.
The incidence of epiglottitis has decreased in the last few years
with the use of the vaccine for type B Haemophilus influenzae.
An artificial airway and intravenous antibiotics have decreased
mortality from 6.1% to less than 1.0%. Adults who aspirate a foreign
body sometimes relate a history of choking, but as previously noted,
one in three may not recall any such episode. Endoscopic evaluation
is needed in most aspiration cases.
Unilateral vocal cord paralysis usually causes hoarseness but is
not accompanied by significant respiratory distress. However, it
can lead to difficulties in swallowing and recurrent aspiration.
The paralyzed vocal cord may be augmented by injecting a Teflon
suspension or be addressed via laryngoplasty with insertion of material
that moves the vocal cord medially.
Bilateral vocal cord paralysis (after thyroidectomy, for example)
may be missed because of near-normal phonation. The patient might
remain relatively asymptomatic at rest but may be symptomatic during
exercise or an upper respiratory infection. Tracheostomy is generally
required to relieve the obstruction.
Patients with suspected obstructive sleep apnea should undergo
a diagnostic and a titration study to determine the amount of positive
airway pressure needed to relieve the obstruction. Surgery of the
upper airway may benefit a select group of patients.
In patients with evidence of tracheal stenosis, several therapeutic
options are available including balloon dilatation, laser therapy,
stent placement, and resection. Laser therapy can be palliative
for patients with malignant tracheobronchial lesions. Lasers also
can excise weblike tracheal stenosis and treat benign granulomatous
lesions obstructing the airway. Bronchoscopic dilatation is another
option in subglottic and tracheal stenosis, using either a rigid
bronchoscope or Jackson dilators. This is usually a temporizing
measure, since most symptoms recur. Resecting the stenotic segment
and reanastomosing the remaining segments is also possible; the
success rate is about 87% when the procedure is performed by experienced
hands.
Stent placement can also be used to treat subglottic and tracheal
obstruction and is most beneficial in treating lower tracheobronchial
benign lesions. In malignant lesions, the tumor usually recurs and
reoccludes the opened airway. For distal obstructions, other invasive
techniques are used for palliation. Some of the methods in addition
to stents are radiation (external or local brachytherapy), laser
therapy, cryotherapy, and bronchoscopic debulking of the lesion
with forceps.
|
Suggested
Reading
Aboussouan LS and Stoller JK: Diagnosis and management of
upper airway obstruction. Clin Chest Med 15:35, 1994.
Christopher KL, et al.: Vocal-cord dysfunction presenting
as asthma. N Engl J Med 308:1566, 1983.
Guntupalli K, et al.: Usefulness of flow volume loops in
emergency center and ICU settings. Chest 111:481, 1997.
Holden DA and Mehta AC: Evaluation of wheezing in the nonasthmatic
patient. Cleve Clin J Med 90:345, 1990.
Hyatt RE and Black LF: The flow-volume curve. Am Rev Respir
Dis 107:191, 1973.
Kryger M, et al.: Diagnosis of obstruction of the upper and
central airway. Am J Med 61:87, 1976.
Miller RD and Hyatt R: Evaluation of obstructing lesions
of the trachea and larynx by flow-volume loops. Am Rev
Respir Dis 108:475, 1973.
Miller RD and Hyatt RE: Obstructing lesions of the larynx
and trachea: Clinical and physiologic characteristics. Mayo
Clin Proc 44:145, 1969.
Newman KB, et al.: Clinical features of vocal cord dysfunction.
Am J Respir Crit Care Med 152:1382, 1995.
Whyte RI, et al.: Helical computed tomography for the evaluation
of tracheal stenosis. Ann Thorac Surg 60:27, 1995.
|
|